Touchception?

The NFL replacement officials had not gotten a call so wrong that it caused the effect of the game. It did tonight. September 24, 2012. Russell Wilson threw a touchdown to Golden Tate, but was it really a touchdown to give the Seattle Seahawks a 14-12 win over the Green Bay Packers?

In the words of Aaron Rodgers, “It’s awful. Just look at the replay…It’s awful, that’s all I’m going to say about it.”

Let’s look at the evidence. Here is a sequence of photos:

What’s the call there, sir?

It appears Packers S M.D. Jennings caught the interception.

Clearly, the replacement officials have no clue what they are doing.

Rule 8 – Section 3 – Article 1 – Item 5: Simultaneous Catch. If a pass is caught simultaneously by two eligible opponents, and both players retain it, the ball belongs to the passers. It is not a simultaneous catch if a player gains control first and an opponent subsequently gains joint control. If the ball is muffed after simultaneous touching by two such players, all the players of the passing team become eligible to catch the loose ball.

According, the photo above, Green Bay Packers safety M.D. Jennings has possession of the football before Seattle Seahawks wide receiver Golden Tate subsequently gained joint control, ruling out it isn’t a simultaneous catch.

Here’s the video of the play. Watch first the “push off,” by Golden Tate, and resulted in a no call. However, it should have been pass interference. Next, watch who gained control of the football first: Jennings or Tate?

Also, remember this may not have happened had offensive pass interference been called on Sidney Rice, instead of defensive pass interference on Sam Shields. Just food for thought.

No matter what, the NFL has to do something about the replacement officials. It is hurting the integrity of the game. The ball is in your court, Mr. Goodell.

Good night.

Advertisements

Cowboys Classic: Michigan vs. Alabama Preview

The last time Michigan and Alabama played each other was in the 2000 Orange Bowl when the Maize and Blue defeated the Crimson Tide 35 to 34 in overtime. Tom Brady was the quarterback, and threw for four touchdowns. Brady twice led the Wolverines back from 14 point deficits tying game at 28 in third. A scoreless fourth quarter led to the first overtime game in BCS history. Brady led Michigan down the field for the touchdown as Alabama missed the extra point. Can Denard Robinson lead Michigan to big win in his final year?

Will tomorrow’s Cowboys Classic be just as fun? Let’s find out what each team has to do to win:

Three keys for Alabama vs. Michigan:

1. Stop Denard Robinson

Alabama is the defending BCS national champion, and return just four defensive starters. Their biggest test is stopping the senior Denard Robinson. Last year, the defense led the nation in four major defensive categories: total yards, rushing, passing, and scoring defense.

Junior linebacker C.J. Mosley, senior safety Robert Lester, and senior nosetackle Jesse Williams are returning big names for the Crimson Tide. Mosley had 37 tackles and 2 sacks a year ago. Lester had 39 tackles and two interceptions and Williams had 24 tackles.

Nick Saban has had since spring ball to prepare for Denard Robinson. I am sure he will be ready.

2. Run the football 

Michigan lost two big defensive lineman in Mike Martin, and Ryan Van Bergen and Alabama should take notice of it.

Yes, Alabama lost Trent Richardson, but senior Eddie Lacy returns after rushing for 694 yards and 7.1 yards a carry last year. Not to mention Alabama has a beastly offensive line led by Outland Trophy winner Barrett Jones (left center to tackle, tackle D.J. Fluker and guard Chance Warmack.

Watch for freshman tailback T.J. Yeldon, who had 179 total yard in Alabama’s spring game.

3. A.J. McCarron needs to be a game manager. 

A.J. McCarron is coming off a big national championship win

A.J. McCarron managed Alabama’s 2012 BCS National Championship win against LSU. He went 23 for 34 for 234 yards in the game, and was named offensive MVP. It certainly helps with a great offensive line and a returning running back.

Last year, McCarron completed 66.8% of his passes threw for 2,634 yards and 16 touchdowns.

When you have a stellar defense, all you have to learn is how to manage games. A “younger” defense is going to be on top of their game to help pick McCarron up.

3 keys for Michigan vs. Alabama: 

1. Look past the suspension of Fitzgerald Toussaint. 

It will be hard for Michigan to be without Fitzgerald Toussaint tomorrow against Alabama. Toussaint was a 1,000+ yard back a year ago, but he had to pay the price for getting arrested. Now, Michigan is without the junior back.

Thomas Rawls, and Vincent Smith have to take pressure off Denard Robinson by finding holes because that is exactly what Toussaint did a year ago.

Vincent Smith is a veteran and will be looked to fill the loss of suspended running back Fitzgerald Toussaint.

Both Rawls and Smith averaged six yards a carry in 2011, and have monster left tackle Taylor Lewen opening gaps to run for them. Lewen is 6’8″ and 309 pounds and started 13 games a year ago.

2. Contain Alabama

Alabama is a grind it out team. They love to run the ball, and pass when you expect the run. Michigan loses Martin, and Van Bergen, but return Craig Roh, who had 32 tackles and 4 sacks a year ago. Will Campbell also returns to anchor the line. They face a tough offensive line, and mounts a big challenge.

The biggest playmaker on defense that must be big is senior Jordan Kovacs. Kovacs is a former walk-on, and now captain. He had 75 tackles and 4 sacks last year.

Also, the Wolverines have senior linebacker Kenny Demens, who had 94 tackles and 3 sacks a year ago. A possible player to watch is freshman Royce Jenkins-Stone, who had 145 tackles as a senior in high school. Also, watch second year cornerback Blake Countess. Countess started the final six games last year, and had six pass break ups.

3. Denard Robinson must be great

Denard Robinson is the key to the game for Michigan

Denard Robinson is known for his running, and his passing can be great and bad at the same time. The biggest factor Robinson has going for him is he is facing seven new defensive starters for Alabama.

Robinson has to be nearly perfect for Michigan to win. About every Michigan fan knows that. He has senior wide receiver Roy Roundtree to count on, who has 123 career catches.

Robinson completed just 55% of his passes and had 15 interceptions last year. He can’t have many, if any turnovers against the Crimson Tide because they will capitalize on them. Robinson must be on the money with his throws.

It should be a fun game to watch, and whoever loses it may break their national championship hopes!